Privacy: Google+ vs. Facebook

By Jonathan Riggall on 11 July, 2011

Google+ may be more than "just" a social network, but it can be used in in a similar way to Facebook, and many people want to join precisely because they want a change. Facebook has suffered a number of privacy scares as it has grown, so how does it compare with new kid Google+? Let's take a look at the  privacy options of both social apps.

Privacy Settings:

Facebook's privacy dashboard has a neat table that shows you who can see what. Click Customize and you can edit these settings. You can choose to share things with just you, friends, friends of friends or specific people. You can also opt to hide certain categories from specific people. Here you can also preview your profile as it appears to any of your friends.

The Google+ privacy settings page is much longer, but every segment is clearly explained. Editing your settings takes you to your profile, letting you see exactly which part of your profile you are altering. Google+'s Circles means you choose who can see your posts and updates as you make them, giving you much greater control.

While their approaches are different, I think both are good attempts at making privacy and sharing settings accessible and user friendly.

Default Settings

Where Facebook and Google+ really differ is default settings. Facebook, in my opinion, gets default settings wrong. As you can see in the image above, unless you actively investigate your settings, Facebook will automatically share your Status, Photos, Posts, Bio and Family/Relationship info with everyone! Worse still, this is the recommended setting. Default settings for apps are usually as open as possible, so it's also worth checking out the settings for apps and websites you have linked with Facebook.

Google+ does this differently. As you create your profile, you set up who can see what as you go. This gets users involved with privacy settings right from the get-go, which I think is a much better approach.

Photo Privacy

Some people don't like being tagged, meaning their Facebook experience revolves around quickly responding to notification emails, jumping in and un-tagging themselves from images.  Google+ by default lets people in your Circles tag you in images, but you can change this so your approval is required for tagging. Approval for tagging is an excellent feature that stops any embarrassing/unwanted photos taking you by surprise!

Conclusion

Facebook's privacy options have changed a lot over the years, and have certainly improved. However, I think they need tighter default settings. There are still many users who are maybe not tech-savvy enough to realize how much they share publicly on Facebook. Google+, with its Circles feature, makes controlling who sees what very easy. Privacy settings are also much more flexible, and your images are much easier to control. It looks like Google has listened to people's concerns about Facebook privacy, and made a social network/sharing experience that is built on user control of data. Google+ is still a very young product though, and it remains to be seen if all this user control makes for a better social experience or not.

Below are some more images of Google+'s privacy settings:

Comments

  • shiromasa yamamoto shiromasa yam<br />amoto

    Let's see Facebook Facial Recognition + 750 million users data + like button tracking on web, Google +Over 1 billion users data + new social networking site that won't let users make profiles private, and patriot act?! Can you say "Big Brother"?! That's why I like onlymeworld, facebooks alternative, no real names, no emails, no hassles, no privacy violations. Site maybe 10% finished, and not as savvvy as others right now, but I choose my privacy & freedoms, over a totalitarian system anytime!

    • Sent on 11 Jul 2011
  • Vinit Vinit

    Google+ Better than Facebook...and the technology google+ is very precosious......

    • Sent on 17 Jul 2011
  • Brian Brian

    Hi Pleaseeee could you send me an invite to google+ , my email is brian.breman@gmail.com Thank you very much.

    • Sent on 18 Jul 2011
  • Čizmadia Čizmadia

    Thank you very much, my email is diapreuge.izmadia@gmail.com

    • Sent on 18 Jul 2011
  • finga finga

    google+ is just a copy of Facebook. they take advantage of the weakness of the other. nothing new. I prefer Facebook....

    • Sent on 18 Jul 2011
  • johanes BOB johanes BOB

    i wanna try google+ can u invite me ? please add me, my email is basabelolon@gmail.com..thank you very much.

    • Sent on 18 Jul 2011
  • althea366 althea366

    it sounds good i am interested

    • Sent on 18 Jul 2011
  • internetguro internetguro

    try www.zukto.com it has been in the social networking industry I think more than 5-8 years before Facebook etc..

    They do not sell your information like Facebook and more than 400.000 application providers that sells your information on the market.

    • Sent on 18 Jul 2011
  • margaretha wegerif margaretha we<br />gerif

    It seems good but I need to give it some thought.

    • Sent on 18 Jul 2011
  • COOKS COOKS

    There's a new network, Fistrocket, which enjoins both oustanding sets of qualities.

    • Sent on 19 Jul 2011
  • samantha xxx:* samantha xxx:<br />*

    :D

    • Sent on 19 Jul 2011
  • baljit dhillon baljit dhillo<br />n

    i like it

    • Sent on 21 Jul 2011
  • carmen attard carmen attard

    can you send me an invite pls

    • Sent on 24 Jul 2011
  • carmen attard carmen attard

    my email is joalcamiro55@hotmail.com

    • Sent on 24 Jul 2011
  • Leonardo Leonardo

    Hi Pleaseeee could you send me an invite to google+ , my email is op.leonardo@gmail.com Thank you very much.

    • Sent on 25 Jul 2011
  • vj vj

    ang ganda ng photos cape ha

    • Sent on 26 Jul 2011
  • Mohit Mohit

    I want to try google plus plsssssss invite me my email address is smohit0997@gmail.com

    • Sent on 28 Jul 2011
  • Kartik Panchal Kartik Pancha<br />l

    I REALLY LIKE THIS.....

    • Sent on 28 Jul 2011
  • julian dialao julian dialao

    yea,, i like..

    • Sent on 28 Jul 2011
  • priyantha viidana priyantha vii<br />dana

    like this

    • Sent on 29 Jul 2011
  • bilalbukharishah bilalbukharis<br />hah

    like this

    • Sent on 29 Jul 2011
  • zoya zoya

    i love is saet

    • Sent on 29 Jul 2011
  • rex rex

    nick job

    • Sent on 01 Aug 2011
  • Alison Alison

    I like to give it a shot.

    • Sent on 03 Aug 2011
  • roya533 roya533

    I LIKE TO GIVE IT.

    • Sent on 03 Aug 2011
  • mahnoor ahmad mahnoor ahmad

    nice

    • Sent on 04 Aug 2011
  • vanuklian vanuklian

    I also like this.

    • Sent on 05 Aug 2011
  • anuraj anuraj

    liks this

    • Sent on 07 Aug 2011
  • mary mary

    i still dont know

    • Sent on 07 Aug 2011
  • swethankumar swethankumar

    I also like this.

    • Sent on 10 Aug 2011
  • mojtaba mojtaba

    i love is saet

    • Sent on 12 Aug 2011
  • ahmed ahmed

    ahmed

    • Sent on 17 Aug 2011
  • tanga307 tanga307

    I want to try google+,Will somebody send me invitation ?

    • Sent on 19 Aug 2011
  • tanga307 tanga307

    I want to try google+,Will somebody send me invitation ? my mail is --tanga307@gmail.com,,, if anybody is online send me now. Thanx in advance.

    • Sent on 19 Aug 2011
  • michael ukpabi michael ukpab<br />i

    will u pay me to send to invitation.

    • Sent on 20 Aug 2011
  • michael ukpabi michael ukpab<br />i

    will u pay me to send to invitation.

    • Sent on 20 Aug 2011
  • gila gila man gila gila man

    FACEBOOK is better than google i think..

    • Sent on 21 Aug 2011
  • moyrichie moyrichie

    i love play

    • Sent on 26 Aug 2011
  • muhammed ali muhammed ali

    i love plsy

    • Sent on 27 Aug 2011
  • sabihee sabihee

    its so so invite me sabihee@gmail.com

    • Sent on 28 Aug 2011
  • lolo lolo

    its so hoooottt...nice piece of work

    • Sent on 29 Aug 2011
  • jitumali jitumali

    awesome

    • Sent on 30 Aug 2011
  • อภิชาติ อภิชาติ

    hctc

    • Sent on 31 Aug 2011
  • bla bla

    blah...

    • Sent on 01 Sep 2011
  • fauzi fauzi

    ha ha ha

    • Sent on 04 Sep 2011
  • Zdravko47 Zdravko47

    I want to try google plus please invite me my email address is zdravko.galovi2@gmail.com

    • Sent on 06 Sep 2011
  • azi azi

    hiiiiiiii

    • Sent on 06 Sep 2011
  • ayush namdev ayush namdev

    Hello. I am ayush namdev and you

    • Sent on 10 Sep 2011
  • abrizzle88 abrizzle88

    If Google+ had more people on it...I would never look at Facebook again!

    • Sent on 14 Sep 2011
  • cute fari cute fari

    hy m new i

    • Sent on 15 Sep 2011
  • Comment

Softonic on Facebook